Box Turtle Bulletin

Box Turtle BulletinNews, analysis and fact-checking of anti-gay rhetoric
“Now you must raise your children up in a world where that union of man and box turtle is on the same legal footing as man and wife…”
This article can be found at:
Latest Posts

Posts for December, 2009

Marriage equality to be recognized in Dutch Caribbean islands

Timothy Kincaid

December 29th, 2009

sabaThe Kingdom of the Netherlands includes six islands in the Caribbean Sea. Three, Sint Eustatius, Saba and Sint Maarten, are in the Northern Caribbean near the Virgin Islands, and three, Aruba, Curaçao and Bonaire, are in the South, off the Venezuela coast.

Currently, the Dutch are in the process of restructuring the borders and autonomy of the various entities. And part of that process is determining the extent to which Dutch Law will apply to local administration.

The Netherlands is one of the seven nations in which (along with a few states and localities) same-sex marriage is recognized. And when it comes to same-sex couple recognition, it appears that the Kingdom will insist that there be no discrimination. (the St. Maarten Daily Herald)

Married and registered gay couples will obtain legal protection against discrimination by government agencies in the BES islands Bonaire, St. Eustatius and Saba after the islands have obtained their new status as public entities in the Dutch Kingdom.

it is the intention of the Dutch government to incorporate a new article in the BES Implementation Law stating that weddings and registered partnerships executed in the Netherlands confer the same legal rights as weddings executed in the public entities.

As Antillean law is replaced with Dutch law, the conducting of marriages on the BES islands will become legal.

It is not immediately clear how this will impact Aruba, Curaçao, or Sint Maarten, but we know that Curaçao has taken steps to attract gay tourists.

A gay bashing event on St. Maarten brought into question the commitment of local authorities to provide safety for gay tourists there. But after an initial response that appeared apathetic, authorities decided that it was in their interest to improve relations.

Attitudes throughout the Caribbean may not be as affirmative as could be wished, but those planning on vacations in the sun may consider those Caribbean islands that are under Dutch influence to be better choices.

Baby it’s Cold Outside… But Not in Curaçao

Timothy Kincaid

December 9th, 2007

curacao1.jpgGay travelers wishing to enjoy the turquoise waters, pristine beaches, and colorful fish of the Caribbean often find themselves limited in their choices.

Some islands, like Jamaica, are so hostile to gays that those who value their safety should never venture there. Churches on the island are vitriolic in their condemnation and, spurred on by murder-minded anti-gay popular musicians, on several instances local gays have been attacked or killed by homophobic mobs.

Other islands seem conflicted in how to respond to gay tourists. Granada recently was caught in confusion when they discovered that a gay travel group was choosing a couple of cruises that included the port city of St. Georges as a destination.

Thinking that this was an all-gay charter, they were contemplating banning the ships. As word got out, however, hotels reported cancellations and negative press in Canada caught the attention of the tourism board. As did fear that the Canadian government may consider cutting off humanitarian support for St. Georges.

The government quickly decided that all travelers are welcome, but the initial response revealed a basic misunderstanding and fear of gay men and women.

In contrast to those islands, the Toronto Star’s Julia Steinecke brought news today of a Caribbean island that not only allows gay tourists, but is making an effort to draw and welcome them: Curaçao.

This small Southern Caribbean island off the coast of Venezuela is part of the Dutch Antilles. It boasts pristine beaches, beautiful Dutch architecture, eco-tourism, outstanding diving, and a website set up for gay tourists:

Curaçao’s tourism board has been hyping the island’s gay-friendly vibe since 2004 when it launched a dedicated website at Now there are 17 businesses in the IGLTA (International Gay and Lesbian Travel Association:, the highest membership for the Caribbean.

Everyone credits the Dutch influence, here in the Netherlands Antilles; I’d also acknowledge the local multicultural mosaic for creating an environment where diversity is the norm.

And as the Dutch government has made a commitment to advancing gay rights abroad, Curaçao can be expected to continue its welcoming attitude.

Curaçao’s motto is We Live and Let Live (“Biba i Laga Biba”). And that can be seen in the island’s long history of welcoming those who were outside of the majority. It prides itself on being a haven for Jews fleeing the persecution of the Spanish Inquisition and hosts one of the oldest continuing synagogues in the Western Hemisphere.

As with all foreign countries, travel should take into consideration such issues as economic unrest, political strife, and other current social upheaval. And not having visited there, I cannot confirm that the island is a paradise or that gay people are truly welcomed with outstretched arms. But with the overt hostility of much of the Caribbean, these words of welcome make me want to come spend time on their beaches:

“It is important to us that it’s known to the gay & lesbian community that everyone is welcome in Curaçao. Our island offers diverse culture, art galleries, beaches, museums, fine accommodations and exquisite cuisine that are enjoyed by all visitors to the island.” commented the Executive Director of the Curaçao Tourist Board

And those feeling Jack Frost nipping may want to know that it’s 77 degrees there right now. And a suite in a four star hotel affiliated with the IGLTA is less than a standard hotel room in NYC.