Box Turtle Bulletin

Box Turtle BulletinNews, analysis and fact-checking of anti-gay rhetoric
“Now you must raise your children up in a world where that union of man and box turtle is on the same legal footing as man and wife…”
This article can be found at:
Latest Posts

Hutch’s Disrupting Protest

Timothy Kincaid

April 25th, 2008

hutch.bmpOne of the consistent (and consistently stupid) claims of the anti-gay wacktivists is that the Day of Silence is “disrupting” of schools. Sitting there silent (unless called on in class) disrupts the education process by (silently) shoving your views down the throats of other students (the other frequent but oddly chosen catch phrase), ya see.

So Rev. Ken Hutcherson decided to protest, along with 1,000 of his prayer buddies.

Well, the Day of Silence has come and gone at the Mount Si High School. And how did Hutch do in quelling the disturbance?

Well, let’s see…

Around 7 am about 80 parents and supporters of the Gay-Straight Alliance came and silently stood to welcome those students observing the DOS.

“We want to let students in the GSA know they have support in the community,” said Lucinda Hauser, a parent of a Mount Si student.

Then at 9:30 am, Hutcherson’s bus showed up with him, his bodyguards, and about 100 supporters. Although he had placed an add in the local newspaper and was hoping for 1,000 angry anti-gays, he didn’t come close to meeting his goal. Hutcherson’s group began to pray and sing and wave signs with messages such as “Silence for Unnatural Behavior? Not ME”.

The parents and supporters had left around 8, not wanting to deal with Hutch and crew. But another group of about 150 counter-protestors were there to challenge the anti-gays. Some, it seems, were from Tolt UCC Congregational Church who ran an ad of support for the students in the same newspaper.

Ken Lauren, a Redmond parent whose son-in-law teaches at Mt. Si, shouted, “Are these the values you want your kids to grow up with — bigotry, intolerance, hatred.” He carried a sign that said, “I believe in separation of church and hate.”

The chaos outside was in contrast to the silence inside. About 200 of the 1,400 students took part in the effort to honor Lawrence King and to draw attention to discrimination and violence against gay kids.

But theirs was not the only message. The Mt. Si Conservative Club passed out red, white and blue ribbons to display their opposition to the silent students.

Inside the school, students and administrators said there were many T-shirts expressing opposing views and some intense discussions.

And to avoid all the conflict (or, more likely, because they could get away with it), about 500 students stayed away from school.

So how well did Rev. Hutcherson do in his quest to stop the disturbing effect of the Day of Silence at his daughter’s high school? Perhaps it would do to compare Mt. Si to other schools in the area.

Seventeen of 19 high schools in King County participated in the National Day of Silence, but none of the other schools had any of the tense moments seen in Snoqualmie.

So I guess we can say that Hutch didn’t succeed in his goal of bringing order from chaos. But some have doubts that this was his goal anyway.

Reverend Hutcherson and his supporters said they were there because they didn’t think school is the place for a demonstration about sexuality.

However, school officials think Hutcherson’s stand may be pay-back after teachers, since disciplined, heckled him at a civil rights assembly. And the school says Friday’s tolerance should be a lesson to both students and parents alike.

“The reverend is going to do what he’s going to do,” said Mt. Si High School principal Randy Taylor. “We certainly are disappointed that he’s taken this form of protest on a student-initiated, student-organized activity.”

I’ll bet Taylor is praying that Hutch decides on private schooling soon.

Comments

POST COMMENT | COMMENT RSS 2.0 | TRACKBACK URL

Emily K
April 25th, 2008 | LINK

Mt. Si Conservative Club? WTF??? Is that like, “social conservative but fiscal liberal”? or, in other words, “not conservative at all?” How many students are in this group?

I’m curious about the opposing t shirts.

Scott
April 25th, 2008 | LINK

Bring order from chaos!!! I love that Tim, you are such the Borg Queen! :)

Joel
April 26th, 2008 | LINK

“Inside the school, students and administrators said there were many T-shirts expressing opposing views and some intense discussions.”

Hmmm.. coem to think of it, this is like a 1st hand experience of a humanities/social studies/theology/etc… Def worth goin to school for it. Education is not all books.

Regan DuCasse
April 26th, 2008 | LINK

Bodyguards…BODYGUARDS?! WTF…?!
For THIS burly, no neck guy? At a high school situation to which he was NOT invited and came in, bullhorn blazing?

Is he SUCH a wussy boy that he wants to look important, or at least undersome threat…? By WHO?
Matt Barber is a big, barrel chested no neck guy too and a Concerned Woman.

Folks, just the other night, those of us who volunteered to squash the marriage ban amendment, had a party. Mostly attended by gays and lesbians and transfolks and their straight allies.
There were school teachers, law enforcement officers, lawyers, activists and students. Artists and writers and folks who work in tourism.

I look at my friends, and think of how scared Ken Hutcherson is of gay CHILDREN in high school, or how frightened Matt Barber is of my friends…I really can laugh my ass off.
I don’t think I’ve seen such intense cowardice in grown assed men in my LIFE!
If not for the terrible loss of young King and the assaults and mental abuse of young gay folks going on…this really would be funnier than a boatload of clowns.

I think I could put in a call to Mr. Hutcherson and tell him he looked like a damn fool and what an embarrassment he is, having bodyguards and being such a big man…I’m not afraid of gay folks or their parents and friends…why is HE?
What a WUSS!

Leave A Comment

All comments reflect the opinions of commenters only. They are not necessarily those of anyone associated with Box Turtle Bulletin. Comments are subject to our Comments Policy.

(Required)
(Required, never shared)

PLEASE NOTE: All comments are subject to our Comments Policy.