Box Turtle Bulletin

Box Turtle BulletinNews, analysis and fact-checking of anti-gay rhetoric
“Now you must raise your children up in a world where that union of man and box turtle is on the same legal footing as man and wife…”
This article can be found at:
Latest Posts

Who will oppose Montgomery County marriages? UPDATED

Timothy Kincaid

July 26th, 2013

There is debate about whether the decision by Montgomery County (Pennsylvania) Clerk Bruce Hanes to issues marriage licenses to same sex couples is civil disobedience or lawlessness and no one know whether they are truly legal or not, but one question seems to me to be even more confusing: who will oppose him?

When I first heard the news I assumed that the Republican elected officials would step in to halt proceedings. But, so far, that doesn’t appear to be happening and even the expected fiery denunciations appear to be limited to a few fringe legislators.

The County’s district attorney decided that opposing Hanes didn’t fall within her job description: (

Montgomery County District Attorney Risa Ferman, a Republican, said Wednesday evening that a same-sex marriage license wasn’t legally valid under existing Pennsylvania law but “the remedy for issuing an invalid marriage license does not include intervention by the office of the district attorney.”

“The register of wills cannot change the laws of this commonwealth by simply ignoring them,” Ferman said in a statement. “If that change comes, it will be through Pennsylvania courts or the Legislature.”

Pennsylvania Attorney General Katheen Kane, a Democrat, has stated that she will not defend the state’s anti-gay marriage law as she believes it is unconstitutional. And Republican Governor Tom Corbett has, so far, limited his response to a statement from his press officer:

Individual elected officials cannot pick and choose which laws to enforce. All officials are constitutionally required to administer and enforce the laws that are enacted by the Legislature. Only the courts have the power to declare a law to be unconstitutional and to suspend its effects.

But other than tsk-tsking, I can find no evident steps being taken to halt the marriages by those who are empowered to do so. I assume at some point Corbett will make some legal effort or some “family” group will seek to intervene. But I am fairly shocked that marriage licenses have been issued this long without the fierce and angry response that would have been the automatic reaction not so very long ago.


Joining those who say that Mr. Hanes should not be issuing same-sex marriage licenses is the Registers of Wills and Clerks of Orphans’ Court Association, which has voted unanimously that they will not follow Hanes’ lead. (Patriot News)

Larry Medaglia, the Berks County Register of Wills, who authored the resolution, said all the members present at conference agreed they would not issue licenses to gay or lesbian couples.

“The only way that is going to change given the resolution and the sentiment in the room and all the discussion is if the Legislature and the governor enact a different law or if the courts should overturn it and mandate a change,” said Medaglia, a former president of the association. “We don’t have the authority to do what Bruce Hanes is doing in Montgomery County. Frankly he doesn’t have the authority to do it.”

Behaving exactly how one would imagine an association of county clerks to behave, the issue of whether same-sex marriage should be legal didn’t arise.

But irrespective of the resolution, they have no authority over Hanes or his decision and will take no steps to compel him to stop.



F Young
July 26th, 2013 | LINK

FYI: Pennsylvania court officials approved a resolution to not issue marriage licenses to gay, lesbian couples, but cannot stop Montgomery County clerk Bruce Hanes from continuing to issue them.

July 26th, 2013 | LINK

As for those “family” groups, who would have standing to make a challenge?

(And the following is not a complaint, so please don’t take it as one. It’s actually amusement: on this site, right this moment, I’m looking at an ad for a dating service whose only options are “I’m a man seeking a woman” and “I’m a woman seeking a man.” I don’t expect them to get much business from Box Turtle Bulletin readers, but if they *want* to bark up the wrong tree, I guess that’s their business.)

Jim Burroway
July 27th, 2013 | LINK

Those ads are served by Google, and the ads that you see are based on what Google thinks you care about, for whatever reason. When I bought some swimwear online earlier this year, I saw nothing but swimwear ads everywhere I went, including BTB. I recently made reservations to stay at a luxury resort hotel in Phoenix for Labor Day weekend. Now I’m seeing ads for resort hotels in Phoenix, also on BTB and elsewhere. Creepy.

Timothy Kincaid
July 26th, 2013 | LINK


Believe it or not, we actually do get quite a few straight readers. But I doubt many will click the “Ladies On Line Now” add that is currently showing so that they can meet Liliya in Odessa, Ukraine.

July 26th, 2013 | LINK

I live in a liberal bubble but for most people it seems like a non-issue. Those that are making any noise about it are mostly supportive – local news outlets seem to be treating the story neutrally-to-positively. Tonight there was a story about a tiny group of Right to Life activists protesting, but that’s the most coverage of “anti” position I’ve seen. Corbett is definitely not out in front of the issue – in news items his statements appear as an afterthought, if at all.

F Young
July 27th, 2013 | LINK

Also of note: Pennsylvania lawmaker calls for impeachment of official issuing gay marriage licenses

Richard Rush
July 27th, 2013 | LINK

F Young, that would be State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, who is well known as Pennsylvania’s most notorious Super Duper Christian supremacist. His most recent stunt was preventing openly gay Rep. Brian Sims from speaking in the House chamber by saying:

I did not believe that as a member of that body that I should allow someone to make comments such as he was preparing to make that ultimately were just open rebellion against what the word of God has said, what God has said, and just open rebellion against God’s law.

If you’re in the mood to be depressed, this should do it: Metcalfe’s district has already elected him eight times as their State Rep.

Leave A Comment

All comments reflect the opinions of commenters only. They are not necessarily those of anyone associated with Box Turtle Bulletin. Comments are subject to our Comments Policy.

(Required, never shared)

PLEASE NOTE: All comments are subject to our Comments Policy.