Box Turtle Bulletin

Box Turtle BulletinNews, analysis and fact-checking of anti-gay rhetoric
“Now you must raise your children up in a world where that union of man and box turtle is on the same legal footing as man and wife…”
This article can be found at:
Latest Posts

Advocate, WaPo, AP Get it Wrong On Anti-Homosexuality Bill

Jim Burroway

February 9th, 2012

Why oh why can’t the mainstream media — or even the LGBT media — get this one right? Here’s the Advocate:

The measure was originally introduced in 2009 by David Bahati and called for same-sex sexual activity to be punishable with the death penalty or life imprisonment. Bahati reintroduced the bill on Tuesday without the death penalty provision, according to the AP, but left life imprisonment in as the maximum sentence for what he calls “aggravated homosexuality.”

And here’s the Associated Press (via Washington Post):

Bahati now says he has rewritten the bill to remove the death penalty provision, leaving life imprisonment as the maximum sentence for what he calls “aggravated homosexuality.”

This follows a similar false report from the BBC which claimed the same thing. The BBC has since made a slight modification to their report (which still carries the false headline “Uganda MP revives anti-gay bill but drops death penalty”) which now tells the real story:

Mr Bahati told the BBC’s Joshua Mmali in the capital, Kampala, that for procedural reasons, the bill had been reintroduced in its original form but that the provision for capital punishment would be removed at committee stage. [Emphasis added.]

The original form, which includes the death penalty, is here. As for the “committee stage”, the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee recommended a sly change to the bill. They recomended removing the explicit language calling for “death by hanging,” and replacing it with a reference to the penalties provided in an unrelated already existing law. That law however specifies the death penalty. Which means that the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee recommended that the death penalty be retained through stealth. Bahati then went on to claim that the death penalty was removed even though it was still a part of the bill.

The bill currently is back in the hands of the Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Committee, the same committee that attempted that sleight of hand trick last May.

Bahati has proven himself an excellent spinner, and writers reporting on the Anti-Homosexuality Bill have consistently failed to verify his words. Until they do, Bahati’s false statements will continue to be presented as though they were facts, and it will be the work of others to demonstrate again that his statements are manifestly untrue. Maybe someday writers for news outlets will begin to behave as journalists and not stenographers. But that day has not arrived.

Comments

POST COMMENT | COMMENT RSS 2.0

Priya Lynn
February 9th, 2012 | LINK

Jim said “The BBC has since made a slight modification to their report (which still carries the false headline “Uganda MP revives anti-gay bill but drops death penalty”)”.

Damn, I wish I would have checked that before I sent the BBC complaint department a “Thankyou” email for updating the story. That really makes me angry.

Paul in Canada
February 9th, 2012 | LINK

BBC is now reporting that Bahati has said the Bill was reintroduced as originally drafted as a “procedural” or technical requirement but that the death penalty would be removed if the Bill moves forward.

Say what? Either the BBC has yet again mis-quoted their ‘sources’ or there is something really shady going on in Uganda!!

Either way, Western media seems to have an impact on Uganda’s spin of this issue and the more we can keep this in the public the better chances we have of the government continuing to ‘distance themselves’ from the Bill and Bahati.

Jay Jonson
February 10th, 2012 | LINK

These people are simply bigots and should never be trusted. You give them too much credit as reasonable people. Of course, they lie, they misrepresent. Anyone who hates homosexuals the way these crazy people will certainly not shy away from committing any other crime.

Priya Lynn
February 10th, 2012 | LINK

I replied to the BBC complaints department noting the false headline on the Ugandan anti gay bill. They replied:

“Dear Ms Lynn,

Our headlines must be fairly short and therefore summarise the story.

The MP who has drafted this bill has told the BBC that he is no longer calling for the death penalty in some instances and is adamant that it will be dropped, even if for procedural reasons it still appears in the text of the bill.

Therefore, I stand by our headline – the MP has dropped this clause.”.

I sent a reply:

Mr. Winter, Bahati has lied before about the death penalty being removed
from this legislation. The MP has not dropped the clause until it is
removed from the legislation. When reporting on this please check the
actual legislation to see whether or not it has been dropped rather than
relying on Mr. Bahati’s possibly false assurances.

Thankyou,

Priya Lynn

Leave A Comment

All comments reflect the opinions of commenters only. They are not necessarily those of anyone associated with Box Turtle Bulletin. Comments are subject to our Comments Policy.

(Required)
(Required, never shared)

PLEASE NOTE: All comments are subject to our Comments Policy.